Call for American Community Survey (ACS) Improvements
Report Publish Date: October 2023
This brief report responds to The Census Project’s May 2023 report “America’s Essential Economic and Social Data at Risk,” which recommends ways to improve and strengthen the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (ACS).
Primary Takeaways
The authors list several ways the usefulness of ACS data could be improved with a larger sample size:
- More annual data for incorporated places of 50,000 or more people.
- More detailed data for smaller incorporated places where the government does not have the infrastructure to collect its own data.
- Releasing three-year data instead of five-year data.
The authors say other ways to improve ACS data’s usefulness—whether or not the sample size is increased—include:
- Improved survey controls for subcounty estimates.
- More survey questions.
- Balancing privacy considerations and data needs.
- Using more administrative records.
- Redesigning how population estimates are made.
Overview and Objectives
In May 2023, the Census Project released “America’s Essential Economic and Social Data at Risk,” which highlights the ACS’s importance for helping policymakers understand the population, housing, and economic conditions in the U.S.
The authors wanted to add additional insights about how the survey’s data is used by federal, state, and local governments, and the private sector. They also wanted to recommend more ways the survey could be improved.
Hypothesis or Approach
The authors quote highlights of the Census Project report, with their own comments below. They also offer a list of “additional options to improve the ACS.”
How This Influences Change
Improved ACS data will be extremely useful for policymakers and public health practitioners working to improve the social determinants of health in U.S. communities. By increasing the sample size, social scientists will gain access to more detailed data that is more representative of the populations they are studying, there will be more respondents, and the power to detect statistically significant findings will increase because outliers will be less likely to affect final survey outcomes.
Grant Details
Amount awarded:
$388,244
Awarded on: 05/25/2021
Timeframe: 2021-2023
Grant number: 78643
Location: Chicago, IL
About Grantee:
Research: Go Deeper
In May 2023, The Census Project released “America’s Essential Economic and Social Data at Risk,” a call to action to support and strengthen the American Community Survey (ACS). The report recommends the following operational and design changes, as well as development of new products and tools:
- Increase sample size and expand Nonresponse Follow-up
- Use more administrative and third-party data
- Include information on relationships among all rostered people
- Add parental place of birth
- Add Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
- Produce higher frequency data products and faster data releases
- Publish products that provide data users with more up-to-date estimates, such as selected monthly statistics
- Design an enhanced microdata access system that would enable data users to create custom, privacy-protected estimates from the full internal microdata file
- Create tools to allow data users to easily combine estimates to produce custom geographic areas and calculate margins of error for derived estimates
These recommendations and other aspects of “America’s Essential Economic and Social Data at Risk” are reviewed in the next section by two former Census Bureau leaders. Their insights stem from decades of experience producing and using population data in the federal government, state government, and private sector. They highlight sections of The Census Project report and offer fresh ideas on how to strengthen the ACS.
Massive Data Institute, McCourt School of Public Policy, Georgetown University, October 2023
Research Team
This study and report was conducted and created by the following:
- Prevost R
- Dick C
- O’Hara A
Similar Research to Explore
Addressing Methodological Issues in Multiracial and Multiethnic Data
Implications and Insights on Federal Revisions to Race and Ethnicity Data Collection
National Public Health Dashboards: Protocol for a Scoping Review
Seeking Funding?
See how you can pave the way to a future where health is no longer a privilege, but a right.