Marketplace Pulse: Limited Choice—How Will Changes in Participation Shape the Individual Market in 2027?
The Marketplace Pulse series provides expert insights on timely policy topics related to the health insurance marketplaces. The series, authored by RWJF Senior Policy Adviser Katherine Hempstead, analyzes changes in the individual market; shifting carrier trends; nationwide insurance data; and more to help states, researchers, and policymakers better understand the pulse of the marketplace.
With open enrollment underway in the individual market for the 2027 plan year, higher premiums and fewer choices are defining features. The median state premium increase is approximately 15%, and many insurers have either exited the market completely or pulled back offerings, creating more areas where choices are limited. At the same time, some existing participants have increased their territories and introduced new kinds of plans. And a few new players have also entered, suggesting that despite the gloom, there are some who see a future in this embattled market.
One notable aspect of individual market participation in 2026 was a decline in on-market offerings coupled with a large increase in off-exchange offerings. In 2026 the number of U.S. counties with only one marketplace insurer increased to 145, and there were 649 counties with only two participants.
Since then, participation has continued to decline. About a dozen insurers have exited the marketplace in advance of 2027 and several others reduced their footprint, by either leaving states altogether or reducing the number of counties in which they offer plans. The result has been to sharply increase the number of counties where only one or two insurers are offering marketplace plans. There are now more than 200 counties with only one insurer and nearly 1,000 where there are just two choices, approximately a 50% increase from 2026. All in all, more than one-third of counties will have limited choices on the marketplace in 2027.
The majority of states (39) will have at least one county where choices are limited. For about half, this is approximately the same as the year before. But for the rest, this represents a significant change, as these states either did not have any counties with limited choice in 2026, or are seeing a major increase in the number of counties where this is the case.
Regional examples
East
- In Connecticut, Emblem's Connecticare Insurance Company will only offer an off-exchange plan, leaving only two marketplace choices in each of the state's eight counties. Centene's exit from New Hampshire and Delaware leaves some or all of these states with only two choices for marketplace plans.
Midwest
- Exits by Cigna, Caresource, and Medica have impacted Iowa and Indiana. Both now have a handful of counties with only one insurer, and Indiana in particular has two or fewer choices in most counties.
West
- The exit of PacificSource Group has left Montana with only two insurers statewide. The market in Oklahoma has also deteriorated, with the exits of Medica and the startup Taro Health Group resulting in about 40 limited choice counties.
South
- The exit of CareSource in West Virginia left Highmark as the sole insurer statewide, an outcome that was averted when provider-sponsored plan Peak Health agreed to enter the marketplace. Cigna and Molina exited Mississippi, and insurer withdrawals have also impacted the once-booming states of North Carolina, Texas, and Georgia.
Thin Blue Line
Blue plans are disproportionately present where choice is limited. For example, in nearly 80% of single insurer counties, the sole choice is a Blue plan. In another 12% of these counties, the choice is Elevance, meaning that state Blue plans or Elevance are present in about nine out of 10 solo insurer counties. This is also the case in counties with two insurers, where one of the choices is either a Blue plan or Elevance about 90% of the time.
This suggests that were it not for the somewhat unique role of Blues plans as a backstop, the threat of a bare county might be higher. Single-state Blues, in particular, are under social and political pressure to participate in much if not all of their state, and do not feel as free to exit unprofitable counties as are publicly traded insurers. United Health Group, Centene, and Oscar largely avoid being the sole insurer, although Centene and United are each in about 300 counties where they are one of two choices.
Participation changes by major players
Some of the major marketplace insurers have increased their footprints somewhat while others have held their ground or even retreated from some markets. Oscar expanded the most, entering six counties in a new state (South Carolina) and increasing its footprint in a number of existing states. Oscar has also added some new plan types, including one for older adults, and have offered some of its plans in combination with supplementary insurance in a partnership with Allstate in a few of their markets.
Centene, the largest individual market insurer, has similarly added some new condition-specific plans in some of its markets, and has entered about 55 new counties in some existing states. Yet it left New Hampshire and Delaware, with the result that its overall footprint is not really changing in terms of total number of counties. United Health employed a similar strategy: it exited Georgia while making a few other expansions so that the overall effect on footprint was neutral. Elevance and state Blues plans, as noted, have made very few changes.
Many of the exits over the past few years have occurred among regional and provider sponsored plans, increasing the amount of consolidation among a fewer number of insurers. With the increased focus on novel plans for specific conditions and age groups, and less interest in standardizing or limiting plan types on the part of federal regulators, we may see an evolution toward an oligopolistic “Pepsi and Coke” type of market where there are only a few insurance companies but more types of plans being marketed to different kinds of consumers.
New entrants
Perhaps surprisingly there are a few new entrants into the marketplace. Much of it can be characterized as disaster mitigation. Peak Health, as mentioned, was recruited to enter the West Virginia market, largely in response to a potential statewide single carrier situation. There are small scale entries in California, Colorado, Minnesota, Indiana, Ohio, and Nevada. Mostly these are collaborations with provider systems and/or local Medicaid plans and represent attempts to fill gaps left by other exits and/or provide some continuity of care for those cycling between Medicaid and the marketplace.
Antidote Health is perhaps the only relatively new insurer with bigger aspirations. It has offered plans in Ohio since 2024 and Arizona since 2025, and is now entering Texas and Georgia, once-hot states that have lost participation from other insurers. Antidote Health describes itself as a company focused on affordability that emphasizes virtual care. Its entries in Texas and Georgia will be on-exchange and are being marketed for CHOICE Arrangements as well as individuals. It will also offer small group coverage in Texas.
Will Limited Choice Limit CHOICE Arrangements?
Support for CHOICE Arrangements (formerly ICHRA) has remained strong among insurers, the broker community, and CMS, but it is worth noting that some of the states that have been enthusiastic boosters of these arrangements have lost a fair degree of participation in the individual market, at least on-exchange. This is true for example, in Indiana, Texas, and Georgia. It remains to be seen whether this is a temporary pause or part of a larger slide, but for now it is fair to say that the promise of choice as an attribute of CHOICE Arrangements is becoming harder to keep in some of these markets. However, much of the marketing of CHOICE arrangements is geared at the off-exchange market where the participation changes may not be as great.
Insurance deserts?
For the individual market as a whole, the decline in participation is sobering but not a fatal blow. The presence of federal and some state subsidies provides an important backstop that will likely prevent a complete meltdown. Yet the prospect of a growing number of counties with little insurer participation is grim, and likely will not bode well for premium increases, morbidity, or enrollment going forward. A recent Wakely analysis found that in the first 6 months of 2026, the individual market declined by nearly 16% and relative risk increased by 6.9%. In addition to the loss of the enhanced premium tax credits and rising costs, there are an array of new administrative hurdles that will complicate enrollment and likely reduce it further.
But while the individual market has some unique problems, its participation trends can also be seen in the context of broader health system malaise. Another manifestation of this is the significant withdrawal from Medicare Advantage, where rising costs and changing reimbursement models have led insurers to flee many markets. Interestingly, while Blues plans may play the role of insurers of last resort in the individual market, this constraint does not seem to apply in Medicare Advantage, and they have found the exit in many states including Texas, Mississippi, North Dakota, Minnesota, and New Jersey.
As heard on many recent earnings calls, insurers have found ways to protect their margins by leaving unprofitable markets, but this does not solve problems for consumers faced with less access and higher prices. The problems extend to employer insurance, where rising costs are increasingly being pushed to employees, leading to financial strain and medical debt. At the same time, the profound shocks to coverage and healthcare system finances that will come from H.R. 1 implementation are just beginning. In its short history, the ACA-compliant individual market has cycled through a unique set of challenges and triumphs. Yet now more than ever, its problems should be seen in the broader context of our healthcare system, which is failing on all fronts to provide people with affordable access to coverage and care.
Related Content
If You Build it, Will They Come?—Off-Exchange Offerings Explode in 2026
Increase in Exits by Individual Market Insurers
Marketplace Pulse
The Marketplace Pulse series, authored by RWJF Senior Policy Advisor Katherine Hempstead, provides expert insights on timely policy topics related to the health insurance marketplaces.