Bare Counties Represent Failure of a Market to Deliver Minimum Services to Consumers
Skip to main content
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
  • Our Vision
    • Our Vision Overview
    • Why Health Equity
    • Focus Areas
    • Measuring RWJF Progress
  • Grants
    • Grants Overview
    • Active Funding Opportunities
    • Awarded Grants
    • Grantee Stories
    • Grant Process
    • Grantee Resources
  • Insights
    • Insights Overview
    • Blog
    • Our Research
    • Advocacy And Policy
  • About RWJF
    • About RWJF Overview
    • Our Guiding Principles
    • How We Work
    • Impact Investments
    • Staff And Trustees
    • Newsroom
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
Find A Grant

Marketplace Pulse: Bare County Jamboree

Brief Jul-19-2017 | Hempstead K | 3-min read
  1. Insights
  2. Our Research
  3. Marketplace Pulse: Bare County Jamboree
2018 County Snapshot 2017-2018 County Population Comparison 2017-2018 County Comparison
Pie chart for K. Hempstead's brief

 

Counties in which no insurer has agreed to enter the health insurance marketplace for 2018, or so called “bare counties,” attract attention because they potentially represent the failure of a market to deliver a minimum of services to consumers. In that way they provide a kind of referendum on the ability of local markets to withstand structural weakness, state policy decisions, and the current climate of federal uncertainty.

At the time of this writing, approximately 40 counties in three states—Indiana, Ohio and Nevada—have no committed insurer to sell exchange plans in 2018. This number will fluctuate as the season progresses. It may grow as insurers announce further exits, which could happen as late as September. It may shrink as state regulators cajole carriers to cover bare areas, which has already happened in a number of states. There has also been a small but important amount of bona fide expansion.

While bare counties may be interesting to market-watchers, they are enormous problems for states, and regulators will do everything they can to fill them. The most likely outcome is that bare counties will be covered by the time open enrollment begins.

The focus on bare counties makes it easy to lose sight of the overall trend in insurer participation. There is no question that the pattern is shifting for 2018.

Based on preliminary data and assuming bare counties are filled, these are the kind of changes we might expect.

More counties will have only one insurer:

  • The share of U.S. counties with one insurer will probably increase from about one-third to closer to 45 percent.
  • In terms of people, while close to 20 percent of the population live in a county with one insurer now, it may be closer to 25 percent next year.

Fewer counties will have many insurers from which to choose:

  • While almost a third of counties (31%) have three or more insurers now, that is projected to be more like 25 percent in 2018.
  • The share of people living in counties with three or more insurers is projected to drop from about 60 percent to a little more than half next year.

Reasonable people can disagree about the magnitude of these changes. On the one hand, the percent of counties with only one exchange insurer is projected to increase by about one-third. On the other hand, more than three quarters of the population will probably still live in a county with two or more insurers in 2018.

But regardless of what one might think about the size of the shift, there is an interesting aspect to the nature of the change. In 2018, the role of national commercial insurers in the individual market will be truly negligible. Of the more than 700 county-level exits announced thus far this year, more than 65 percent came from national commercial carriers. Humana and Aetna have completely exited the exchanges, and United is virtually gone. Cigna will likely remain in a small number of states. Anthem, which functions as a blue plan, has also significantly pruned its participation in a number of states. At this writing, national commercial insurers (excluding Anthem) comprise less than 2 percent of county offerings. This continues but sharply accelerates a trend which began in earnest in 2015. Even that high point marked a notable decline from 2013.

It appears thus far that, at least comparatively speaking, the ACA individual marketplace has not been a favorable environment for this group of insurers. Although some have maintained token footholds in various states—suggesting that they would like to be ready to re-enter were conditions to improve—their role will be minimal in 2018. Due to their importance in the industry writ large, these companies are still considered important stakeholders in current policy debate, despite the fact that they are really not market participants in any meaningful sense.

Meanwhile, over the last few years, the participation of provider sponsored plans, regional plans, Medicaid managed care organizations—and most importantly the blues—has steadily increased, and they are the dominant issuers in the market right now. These companies are far more likely to be locally based, which generally raises the threshold for exit, and thereby requires a greater commitment to the population at hand. It seems that for some this commitment has paid off, since financial performance for many has improved in 2017.

Both friends and foes of the ACA will continue to monitor insurer participation in the months ahead, and the future is far from certain. Yet the charge that the market is “dead” does not stick. The data thus far suggest that most counties will have at least two insurers offering plans on the exchange, and most people will be able to choose from at least three.

Related Content

Brief

Marketplace Pulse: Medicaid and Marketplace Provider Networks

Access to a network of providers is one of the most fundamental benefits of health insurance, especially in highly regulated markets such as Medicare Advantage and the ACA Marketplace.

6-min read

Healthcare Coverage and Access Policy and Law
Brief
Morton County, North Dakota. City of Mandan.
Jessica Barker (left)  (RN Nurse) takes the blood presuure of Vonda Bechtel (right) (office manager).
Custer Health is a five county multi-district health unit providing health services to the people of Mercer, Oliver, Grant, Morton, and Sioux Counties. 
Public Health services provided are environmental health, nursing services, the WIC (Women, Infants, Child) program and family planning services. Each of these programs provides a wide variety of services in order to accomplish the mission of public health which is to assure that North Dakota is a healthy place to live and each person should have an equal opportunity to enjoy good health. To accomplish this mission, we are committed to the promotion of healthy lifestyles, protection and enhancement of the environment, and provision of quality health care services for the people of North Dakota.

Marketplace Pulse: How is Competition Evolving in the Marketplace?

Between 2019 and 2021, participation in the ACA marketplace increased dramatically, while enrollment growth was modest. In 2022, that started to change. An updated map shows changes in participation at the county level.

5-min read

Healthcare Coverage and Access Policy and Law
Brief
Colleen Nielson, Director of the Lake County Public Health Agency, holds a meeting with staff at their office in Leadville, Colorado.

Marketplace Pulse: The Bridge Between Medicaid and the Marketplace - What Role Might MCOs Play in Un...

The synergies between Medicaid and the Marketplace which have been growing for the past several years will soon be put to a real-world test when millions face the loss of their coverage.

6-min read

Healthcare Quality and Value
View all
SHOW MORE
+

SHARE

Subscribe to receive Funding Alerts & more

Explore the latest in reflection and research from subject matter experts at RWJF and our wide network of partners.

Email address already subscribed. Please check your inbox to manage your subscriptions.

Subscribed!

Thank you. You are now subscribed.

Tell us what type of content you want to receive.

Be informed with our weekly newsletter updating you with relevant news and research around a Culture of Health, as well as the latest funding opportunities.

Get funded by RWJF: Receive notifications when new funding opportunities are released.

Receive monthly updates on RWJF-sponsored research that informs many robust health policy debates on Capitol Hill, covering topics like health equity, improving access to quality healthcare, equitable housing, and more.

Shop talk for researchers. This monthly newsletter covers research news and opportunities from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Sometimes we have news, announcements or opportunities that don't quite fit the subscription parameters above. If you're interested, we'll send you this information under "There's more...". *If you've indicated you are an EU resident, we will only send these communications if you intentionally check this box.

Yes! I want to tell you more about myself and receive personalized communications in the future.

Area(s) Of Interest

Which profession or pursuit best describes you?

Unsubscribe

Stop receiving all emails from RWJF

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
  • CONTACT RWJF

    50 College Road East

    Princeton, NJ 08540-6614

     

    US Toll Free: (877) 843-7953

    International: +1 (609) 627-6000

  • MANAGE YOUR GRANTS

    MyRWJF Login

    • Twitter link
    • Facebook link
    • LinkedIn link
    • YouTube link

  • Our Vision
    • Our Vision Overview
    • Why Health Equity
    • Focus Areas
    • Measuring RWJF Progress
  • Grants
    • Grants Overview
    • Active Funding Opportunities
    • Awarded Grants
    • Grantee Stories
    • Grant Process
    • Grantee Resources
  • Insights
    • Insights Overview
    • Blog
    • Our Research
    • Advocacy And Policy
  • About RWJF
    • About RWJF Overview
    • Our Guiding Principles
    • How We Work
    • Impact Investments
    • Staff And Trustees
    • Newsroom
    • Careers
    • Contact Us

©2001- 

Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. All Rights Reserved. 

 

  • Manage Email
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms and Conditions